Search
Generic filters

3.Monitoring

3.1. The monitoring delivery strand underpins the other four delivery strands, ensuring effectiveness of mitigation delivery through ongoing data collection.

3.2. Specific monitoring may be required to evaluate and improve upon all delivery strands. However, there is also a need for regular monitoring activities. The regular monitoring activities identified in the previous Monitoring Plan were: automated counters, car park counts & vantage point watches, data recorded by rangers on site engagement activities, visitor surveys at Suitable Alternative Natural Greenspaces (SANGs), disturbance levels at  sites with rangers, visitor surveys in the SPA, bird numbers and distribution, housing data, SANG creation and enhancement, and ranger time and deployment.

3.3. Automated counters were found to be expensive to maintain and provided misleading data in previous years. Therefore, it is agreed that their use be ceased. Similar data can be acquired from partners’ access to mobile phone data, which is a resource that can be accessed by Bird Aware Solent free of charge.

3.4. Car park counts involve pre-established vehicular transect routes which are simultaneously undertaken. This offers a means to assess how access along the coast is changing over time.

3.5. SANGs in the Solent are effective in deflecting recreational visits away from sensitive coastal areas. However, due to the geography of the Solent area, potential locations for SANG establishment are few in number, limiting the delivery of SANGs. As and when SANGs are brought forward, face-to-face interviews will be implemented to establish whether the SANG is being effective in diverting people.

3.6. Targeted research looking at disturbance levels at rangered sites allows for assessing the effects of ranger presence on visitor behaviour and bird disturbance.

3.7. Wetland Bird Survey (WeBS) counts, organised by the BTO, are to be used to understand local changes in bird numbers across the Solent, as well as individual bird species status on a local level. This will help target mitigation interventions by directing mitigation interventions and tailoring mitigation to target local species.

3.8. In addition, there will now be a need to collaborate with partners in order to monitor breeding bird colonies annually, collecting colony size and evidence of breeding success and failure (for example hatching success, fledgling numbers) to inform where to focus site-based improvements and ranger effort, both through site engagement activities and through other types of engagement such as events, education, and communications

3.9. Additionally, there may be a need for larger, targeted monitoring interventions, shaped by the priorities of the delivery team. These may either help understand emerging trends in recreational disturbance, such as the impacts of watersports, or test the effectiveness of mitigation.

3.10. Some examples of the above will be detailed in this document. However, it is likely that additional projects will require their own monitoring within the lifetime of this document.

Table 2. Planned monitoring activities under the ‘Monitoring’ delivery strand

 

Relevance to Revised Strategy What – Monitoring Activity Who – Responsible for Monitoring Delivery When – Suggested Frequency of Monitoring Why – Rationale for Monitoring & Evaluation How – Suggested Monitoring & Evaluation Methodology
M3 Scale up current monitoring provision Visitor survey Monitoring Officer

Assistant Monitoring Officer

External consultants

Volunteers

Every 5 years (next 2027/2028) An update is needed to ensure understanding of visitor use is up to date and understand visitor patterns to the Solent in the summer months, as this was outside of the scope of prior survey effort. Face-to-face interviews to take place across the Solent. The survey would aim to capture not only visitor numbers across the Solent but also more generally visitor behaviour, user groups, and general awareness of Bird Aware Solent and bird species and disturbance
M3 Scale up current monitoring provision Mobile phone data Partners Annual Understanding where residents of the Solent recreate is key to tailoring rangers’ interventions across the coast. Additionally, within sites, visitor use may not be equally spread, affecting where bird disturbance may occur. Partners such as Hampshire County Council have access to mobile phone data for their sites. This can be used to regularly monitor visitor numbers, provenance, and, to an extent, behaviour while on site.
M3 Scale up current monitoring provision Car park counts Monitoring Officer

Assistant Monitoring Officer

External consultants

Volunteers

Every 2 years (next 2026/2027) Car park counts help establish locations where access is changing and target mitigation, as well as assess how visitor numbers are changing. In particular, an update is needed to understand visitor patterns to the Solent in the summer months, as this was outside of the scope of prior survey effort. Vantage point surveys along pre-established transect routes, with counts of vehicles and associated details at each pre-determined location
M3 Scale up current monitoring provision SANG visitor surveys Monitoring Officer

Assistant Monitoring Officer

External consultants

Partners

Volunteers

Ad hoc SANGs are an established form of mitigation for recreational disturbance. However, it is important to establish whether they are and continue to be effective in diverting people away from the coast. Face-to-face interviews at each SANG when it opens and repeated over time. Partners will also provide key information such as when improvement works or temporary closures are set to occur.
M3 Scale up current monitoring provision Disturbance monitoring Monitoring Officer

Assistant Monitoring Officer

External consultants

Every 5 years (next 2026/2027) Rangers at the coast engaging with visitors is a key component of mitigation delivery. However, due to the large amount of staff time and logistics involved, it is important to know where rangers are most effective so they can have the largest mitigation impact. An update is also needed to understand the effectiveness of ranger site visits at summer breeding sites. Case studies assessing the effectiveness of ranger presence in shaping visitor behaviour and reducing disturbance. Paired visits are made to selected sites while rangers are present or not in order to assess the impact of their presence. ‘Commentary will be provided about how this situation is changing over time.
M3 Scale up current monitoring provision WeBS counts Partners

Public

Annual Bird use will shift year-on-year and over time. Understanding which areas are used by overwintering birds is crucial to correctly tailor mitigation delivery, from ranger presence to site-specific interventions. Request and collate WeBS count data each winter for SPA cited bird species and birds that form the Waterbird Assemblage.
M3 Scale up current monitoring provision Breeding bird data Partners

Public

Annual Bird use will shift year-on-year and over time. Understanding which areas are used by breeding birds is crucial to correctly tailor mitigation delivery, from ranger presence to site-specific interventions. Collaborate with partners to gather data on breeding birds at key sites across the Solent to inform mitigation (location and types of interventions) going forward and, over time, evaluate effectiveness of mitigation delivery at breeding sites.